| | | |

Easy Cooking Substitutions For A Healthier Holiday

The spirit of the holidays is here. And while this time of year is often synonymous with joy, magic, and comfort, the holiday season can equally be a recipe for fatigue, mood instability, and sluggishness. Be it a disruption in your day-to-day routine—or an increase in social gatherings—healthy habits are easy to brush aside. Luckily, a balanced yet satisfying holiday season is within reach. And rest assured: there’s no need to skip dessert or healthify everything you make! After all, ’tis the season to celebrate life. With festivities underway, I’m sharing healthy holiday cooking swaps. Whether you’re hosting or celebrating elsewhere, these are easy ingredient alternatives.

gingerbread cookies_healthy holiday cooking swaps

Why is it hard to eat healthy during the holidays?

For most, it’s hard to eat healthy—and stick to wellness habits—during the holidays. It’s a challenge for a few reasons: loss of routine and control, as well as cultural norms around indulgent eating. Even with good intentions, temptations and expectations throw us for a loop. We’re surrounded by more alcohol and more sugar. Plus, there are more barriers to entry when it comes to exercise (travel, cold weather, busy schedules, etc.). All of that said, it’s important to recognize when you’re simply not prioritizing the things that make you feel your best. Speaking of, the following healthy holiday cooking swaps are one way to consciously support your well-being.

Colorful charcuterie_healthy holiday cooking swaps


Before we dive into healthy ingredient swaps, these are three simple tips to help you manage your blood sugar during the holidays. Keeping blood sugar stable (avoiding massive peaks and dips in your blood glucose) is key for feeling well—year round.


This will help slow the rate of sugar entering your bloodstream. When you’re noshing on charcuterie, aim for nuts, cheese, olives, or prosciutto with crackers. While you may have less control over what’s being served for dinner, opt for a protein-rich and fat-forward breakfast (eggs, sausage, avocado, cheese, berries, Greek yogurt, etc.). Starting your day off with stable blood glucose will support better energy and cravings—all day long.


Water reduces blood sugar by diluting the amount of sugar in the blood. Aim for filtered water with electrolytes (this powder is delicious and has no sugar added). Particularly if you’re drinking alcohol.


This goes without saying, but being physically active significantly reduces insulin resistance and lowers blood sugar. Muscles use up extra blood glucose during exercise, which is why resistance training is so beneficial. However, never underestimate the advantages of walking! After your holiday meals, encourage your family and friends to have a dance party or go for a bundled walk around the block.

Egg skillet_healthy holiday cooking swaps

Healthy Holiday eating guide

Ultimately, the follow guide is meant to steer you to alternatives that taste great and are made with real ingredients—maybe even ingredients with a higher bang for your nutritional buck. These healthy holiday cooking swaps are timeless, practical, and useful. Here are a handful of holistic holiday swaps to make the holidays feel both nourishing and satisfying. The following guide is broken down by appetizers, mains, sides, desserts, and drinks.


Goat and sheep cheese vs. cow’s cheese

Preferably organic, goat and sheep cheeses are often less processed than non-organic dairy options, with a higher nutritional value and better digestibility than cow’s dairy. Goat and sheep milk are also better options for those with dairy sensitivities as there is less lactose (milk sugar) than in cow milk products. 

Nut Cheeses vs. traditional cheese

There are a variety of incredible nut cheeses on the market. They resemble the flavors of traditional cheese without the potential inflammatory side effects of dairy. Nut cheeses are loaded with healthy proteins, fats, and fiber, plus, they’re incredibly delicious. You can order Srimu online, but Treeline and Miyoko’s are more widely available brands.

Veggies and hummus vs. Sausage rolls

Traditional, meat-filled pastry appetizers often tend towards highly processed options that are filled with excess sodium, sugar, and unhealthy fats. Crudités with hummus are filled with more fiber and healthy fats.

Seedy crackers vs. refined flour crackers

Swap traditional crackers for seedy, less refined crackers. I love Ella’s Flats, Flackers, Top Seedz, and Simple Mills. These can improve overall health and digestion. Pair with Bitchin’ Sauce or your favorite pesto.

Homemade roasted Nuts  vs. store-bought

Nuts are great for satiation, blood sugar balance, and are loaded with protein and fiber. Try this homemade roasted nuts recipe.

Fall charcuterie_healthy holiday cooking swaps


Organic Meat vs. Conventional Meat

Organic (and ideally, grass-fed) meat contains no growth hormone or antibiotics, plus a lower fat ratio than conventional meat. Grass-fed animals have more omega 3 fatty acids because they consume more nutrients due to eating grass, their natural diet, versus grain and soy-based feed like conventionally fed animals. You can find organic meat options at Costco as well as online from retailers like First Light

Wild-Caught Fish Vs. Farmed Fish

Wild-caught fish eat a natural diet of algae, krill, and smaller fish. This means that their diet is more varied, whereas farmed fish have a pretty consistent diet and are fed things that fish don’t (and shouldn’t) typically consume. This results in a lower nutrient profile. Farmed fish are also exposed to chlorine and other toxic tank cleaners and given antibiotics. Look for frozen wild-caught options at your local grocery store.

Tempeh Vs. ultra-processed meat alternatives

For plant-based options, opt for tempeh, lentils, and legumes. My friend, Laura, of The First Mess has an endless list of vegan holiday main dishes, desserts, and everything in between. When possible, swap ultra-processed soy meat alternatives (which are typically laden with inflammatory oils) for lentils and legumes. These contain fiber and protein, helping regulate blood sugar.

Tempeh_healthy holiday cooking swaps


Celery root (celeriac) vs. mashed potatoes

A major benefit to mashed celery root is its ability to help balance blood sugar levels. It’s a wonderful option that’s loaded with antioxidants and fiber. Otherwise, try these mashed cauliflower potatoes.  

Root veggies vs. Russet potatoeS

Root veggies—like sweet potatoes, carrots, parsnips, butternut squash, acorn squash, and kabocha squash offer a wide variety of vitamins and minerals, making them an excellent addition to your holiday menu. They’re also loaded with fiber to help regulate blood sugar. When roasting, opt for a neutral, high-heat oil like avocado oil.

leafy Greens vs. iceberg lettuce

Not only do fresh greens offer an alkalizing and high-nutrient option to the dinner table, but they also add variety when it comes to texture. Adding fresh herbs, plus pops of color with seasonal foods—like pomegranate seeds—give salads a dynamic flavor profile and a boost of nutrition. 

sautéed Greens vs. canned peas

Greens, like collards, spinach, and kale, packed with vitamins, minerals, and fiber. Sautéing them helps improve flavor and digestibility. A simple dash of extra-virgin olive oil, lemon, and sea salt for a simple yet delicious side.

Swiss chard_healthy holiday cooking swaps


Unrefined sugar vs. refined sugar

Making dessert for your family? Consider the type of sugar(s) you’re using. Natural sugars, like maple syrup, honey, and dates, are full of vitamins and minerals—think: magnesium and vitamin B. You can also sub regular sugar for low-glycemic sugar options (diabetic-friendly) that taste the same in baked goods.

Altnerative flour vs. gluten flour

Gluten-free flours—like almond flour, cassava flour, and coconut flour—can offer more energy, reduce bloating, and for most, are easier to digest. These are also more blood sugar-friendly than traditional flour. Here’s a list of blood sugar-friendly holiday cookie recipes.

cookies_healthy holiday cooking swaps


sustainable wine vs. traditional booze

Organic wine, like Dry Farm Wines, don’t contain sulfites, additives, or genetically modified ingredients—all of which can trigger hangovers and allergies. Organic grapes are also higher in antioxidants and natural sulfur, so adding these preservatives is unnecessary. Along with Dry Farm Wines, Avaline makes delicious organic wines.

alcohol-free option

For your guests (or you!) who want something more than a sparkling water, there are many alcohol-free tonics and elixirs on the market. Aplós is well-loved, along with Gruvi’s Bubbly Rosé.

Tea after dessert

From ginger and lemon balm to mint and chamomile, all of these herbs can help support digestion. They break down gas, reduce bloating, and promote healthy transit time. According to Ayurvedic science, the warmth of tea also helps promote Agni, the digestive fire, which needs to burn bright for proper digestion.

tea_healthy holiday cooking swaps

This post contains affiliate links. Thank you for supporting Wellness with Edie!

This article is for informational purposes only. It is not, nor is it intended to be, a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment and we recommend that you always consult with your healthcare provider.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *